Paw Patrol, Bakugan, and Betting on Yourself Young

Ronnen Harary, Co-Founder of Spin Master

This interview is part of The CEO Series by Executive House.

Watch the full interview on YouTube

You wrote a book. What was the process?

I wrote half the book. What I did was read a book about writing a book. It's called Bird by Bird, by Anne Lamott, an incredible writer. She says if you're going to write a book, you have to do three things: let yourself write completely unfiltered, be vulnerable, and be authentic. And the last thing she said is you can never wait for inspiration, because it's never going to come. You just need to sit yourself in the chair the same time every day and write unfiltered. I took her advice. After I stepped down as co-CEO of Spin Master, I took a year and a half off on sabbatical. In Tel Aviv, I'm the only person that put a full green grass roof on my apartment, basically a lawn, and I'd go up there and write for two hours every day. The writing process is the most magical thing ever. If you write for two hours straight with no distractions, you get this amazing transmission of your thoughts and insights, and afterwards you're completely high. Better than running, better than yoga, better than anything. I did that for three months and got about 60,000 words. Then my agent, who runs the lit department at UTA, said, "What you've written is really good, but we need to marry you with a ghostwriter." He paired me with Tanner Colby, who's written 20 books. We worked together for a year and a half. He took my body of work, shaped it, interviewed me, pulled more stuff out, and put it in a very readable form.

Was it therapeutic?

The most therapeutic thing was before the book came out, I sat down with my dad and read him the parts he was in, and I did the same with my mother and my two business partners. I was very authentic and vulnerable in the book, especially about my relationship with my parents. It's one thing to give them the book. To read it to them and see their reaction, that was the most cathartic and growth-oriented thing out of writing the book.

You wrote that your parents were emotionally absent when you were growing up. How did they respond?

Emotional neglect. Each of them was different. My mom was really reflective, and she apologized for a bunch of stuff. My dad took it in in his own way. They're my parents, and they did amazing things. They brought me into the world, fed me, put clothes on my back, moved me to Canada. But it was more about the physical aspect. The emotional stuff was very difficult for me. My parents never read to me as a kid. They never acknowledged my learning disability. I was the last guy at hockey trying to find a ride home. My parents were immigrants. We came from South Africa when I was five, and my parents were displaced from their home countries. So you have to recognize where your parents come from too.

Tell me about your learning disability.

I have dysgraphia. As I write, my hand cramps up and my handwriting becomes very illegible, and to read whatever came out of my brain, I have to rewrite the words, and then I forget my thought. It's like I'm a slower 386 computer that has to reboot all the time. I also have some spatial awareness challenges. You never want to pick me for a 1,000-piece puzzle. Even typing, I make spelling mistakes and the thoughts get stuck. It's really frustrating. Imagine you want to get your thoughts out and they're just constricted. But the flip side is you have all these learning gifts. I see the world differently. I read body language really well. I pick up cues from people's voices. You work more on intuition and high concepts, and that plays out really well in your adult life. But when you're a kid in an organized school format, it's very difficult.

Why toys?

Toys actually found us. If you'd asked me in university, I'd have said, "What are you talking about?" We graduated with $10,000 in the bank from a business we ran in university called Campus Faces, pre-internet. My mom was reading the Israeli newspaper, and there was a story about six different people manufacturing a product called Grass Head who had sold 300,000 pieces in a country of 10 million. I said, "No one's doing it in Canada. Why don't we?" My partner Anton thought we were crazy, and it took me two weeks to convince him. We said, let's make 5,000 pieces for Mother's Day. My brother-in-law built the machinery and got 5% profit sharing. My sister designed the packaging and got 5%. And we hired people from a homeless shelter to get started.

Why hire from a homeless shelter?

Nothing more than people are in a homeless shelter because they probably don't have work, and we had work to offer, so let's call them and see. But it didn't scale. So we went to places like immigration centers, and we had a lot of people from Sri Lanka, Eritrea, and Vietnam, and they really helped scale the business.

Do you think the lack of emotional connection growing up drew you to toys?

Maybe on a subconscious level. I didn't grow up with very many toys in the house. The greatest thing about developing toys is you get to be stuck at seven all the time. So maybe there's something about wanting to relive your childhood in a more joyful way. I don't know. But we're super lucky to be in this industry. Our second product was Devil Sticks. We found ourselves at Toy Fair in 1995 in a small room in the back, myself, Anton, and my ex-girlfriend Melissa, and walked out with sales in KB Toys and Toys "R" Us, and sold about a million pieces that year. Then it became a very conscious decision. Our third partner, Ben, was living with a woman whose parents gave us a list of toy inventors. In the toy industry, there are about 200 people whose full-time job is coming up with toy ideas, and you license ideas from them and pay them a 5% royalty in perpetuity. You have this incredible brain trust of talented humans who aren't on your payroll, and if the product does well, you share the profits with them. The barriers to entry were much lower, and you can finance a toy business much more easily than tech.

Why use outside inventors instead of inventing everything in-house?

The best way to get the highest hit rate in our business, and you want to bat 600 in this business, is to see the largest body of work you possibly can. If you review thousands of products a year and select 20, the more you have at the top, the more judicious you can be at the bottom. You force-rank the best. You thought this one was great, but this one's way better. You raise the bar by seeing a lot of stuff. That's one of the secrets of our business. You can't do that with only internal invention, because the body of work is too narrow.

What was the hardest early lesson?

Learning the development process. Air Hogs was our first really complex toy, with CAD, complex molds, multiple pieces coming off the line that had to work. Everybody thought we were crazy, because a flying toy has safety issues and it crashes, so you have return issues, and returns will kill you in the toy industry. You give all your margin back. Air Hogs was actually turned down by Hasbro and Mattel, and we didn't know that until much later. Most toy companies shied away from something that complex. We overshot the bar on our first big toy, and then we could do things that weren't as complex afterwards.

Do Spin Master toys become collector's items?

The closest thing is Bakugan from 2008 to 2010. People are buying them now and reselling them. I play tennis with a 23-year-old coach, and when he found out I was part of Bakugan, he brought me his whole collection. The fact that he saved it since he was eight years old, that he still cared for it, is the best feeling ever.

Where does your comfort with risk come from?

My family understood risk. My parents moved from Israel to South Africa, and then from South Africa to Canada. Moving is a huge risk in itself, and starting over. They had their own small business. My dad was a partner in a Persian carpet gallery for 10 years, and then opened another business that closed. Every night at dinner, 6:30 on the nose, we ate as a family, and the whole conversation was about my parents' business. I loved it. I loved all their clients, all the colorful characters they brought into the house. I loved business from when I was a little kid. I wasn't reading sports or entertainment. I was reading the business section and dreaming about having my own business.

The documentary showed some heated moments between the founders. Do entrepreneurs need thick skin for that?

The most important thing is to have the lowest ego possible. And on the flip side, really healthy dialogue. Diversity of thought is the number one thing. If people are passionate about what they're advocating for, you generate really good ideas. What's really important is that once you recognize the idea, you don't own the idea, you just run with it. Those were the ingredients of our partnership. If people aren't passionate about their point of view, it means they don't care. So the passion, and a chair here or there, means you're into it. The moment the debate and the fighting ends, it means the passion's gone, and when the passion's gone, the business is in trouble. As partners we met every week, flushed out anything that happened during the week, apologized if someone stepped over the line, and cleared the air so we could start fresh. We never left anything lingering.

Did you worry about losing Anton as a friend?

I probably lost him as a friend, but I gained a brother. It's a totally different relationship once you work with someone for 30 years. It's lighter when you're just friends. Here you've got so many other issues in the mix that take up head space and emotions. I wish you could have both. It's just hard to achieve. When I meet people who have both, I'm like, "Wow, how'd you pull that off?"

Walk me through the Bakugan boom and bust.

It was brutal, the worst two years. We couldn't see bottom. Every quarter the sales kept going down. We missed the numbers every single quarter for eight quarters. Luckily we were private, or it would've been a disaster. The amazing thing is it trained us to be a good public company, to forecast, have a stable pipeline, and look three years out. We have a brand innovation pipeline where we're constantly looking at which new products are coming into the pipe, which are at the end of their life cycle, and what the drop-off in sales is, so we can keep the base and grow on top of it. In 2008 we were doing $450 million in sales, and by 2010 we hit a billion. We'd always dreamed about a billion. Two years later we were back to $450 million. Some toys have a life cycle, and we didn't have new products behind it. But the real core was hubris. When you grow from 450 to a billion in two years, you hurdle so much overhead that everything drops to the bottom line. We hadn't taken money out of the business for 14 years. We kept plowing it back in. That was the first time we could take dividends out. And four years later we were putting money back in to recapitalize it. We thought every product we brought to market would be successful, and that wasn't the case. We had to be way more judicious and look at way more products, and we had to watch expenses. We let go of 350 people. We did four restructurings. We'd never done a restructuring before.

What was that like?

The worst. To look at all the people in your company and debate which ones need to leave and which ones stay, and then actually let people go who've been with you a long time. It's the worst part about having a business. And we weren't experienced enough to do it once and get it out of the way. When you do it four times, you're jerking the company every six months. People who didn't get let go were worried about getting let go, so the business was unstable for two years. That's where you get the gray hair. But this is what separates good businesses from average ones: the ones that make it through, rebuild, learn from the experience, keep the partnership going, don't sell, and don't give up. We had to stop thinking everything we touched would turn to gold and get back to what got us there. A lot of humility, and a lot of attention to detail in the products we brought to market. It was like a cold shower that didn't stop for 700 days.

Did that pain create PAW Patrol?

PAW Patrol was born at the lowest point in our company's history. I wouldn't say the pain, but it focused us. It taught us that if you're going to bring things to market, don't dial it in. Give it the time and attention it deserves for the end consumer, so you have the highest chance of success.

Tell me about the inception of PAW Patrol.

Bakugan was our first entry into TV shows. The real reason Spin Master produces its own shows is that when we were younger, every time we went for a license, we got turned down. We could never get an A license from a Disney or a Warner Brothers, and 26% of the toy industry comes from licensed products from TV shows or movies. We weren't getting our fair share, so it forced us into entertainment. Canada has a rich history of making shows for kids, so we started making shows here, and we had three failures: Redakai, Tenkai Knights, Little Charmers. You couldn't give the product away. It felt like it was glued to the shelf. Then we said we've never done anything in preschool, and we've never done anything around transforming toys for preschoolers. That was white space. And the preschool space hadn't had a new show capture the hearts and minds of kids in a long time. We wrote a one-pager asking for ideas around transformation and sent it to five creators around the world. The one we liked most was from Keith Chapman, the creator of Bob the Builder, an amazing human being I'd always wanted to work with. The funny thing is he didn't follow the brief. He did nothing around transformation. But what an idea. It was originally called Rubble and the Rescue Pups. Our toy team added the transformation elements.

How do you build a show and toys together?

First you create the story. We hired two amazing Canadian writers, an amazing director, and an incredible animation studio, and we married them up with our toy designers. We were the first to fuse the two art forms together. If you want a show to translate into things kids want to play with, it needs to be aspirational. If you want kids to care for the characters, it has to be extremely well written, with characters kids can relate to. We learned that from spending many years working with Japanese companies, who marry the two art forms when they bring something into the world. No North American company had done that. Toys are an art form. TV shows are an art form. We had people working together who were like, "Why are we working together?" But from friction comes amazing things. Nobody knew PAW Patrol would become what it became. Everybody was paying attention to the details of their craft, and nobody was dialing it in. We started in 2011, and it first aired in 2013. It's now in 180 countries.

When did you know it was a hit?

A few months later. I'd go on Instagram and look at the number of people making birthday cakes for their kids with the PAW Patrol characters. Every day more people were making cakes. If someone wants to celebrate with your characters, that's a very intimate thing.

What makes something a franchise?

When other people license your characters and put them on their products. We have about 200 licensees every year. It's the best business. They do the product development, take the inventory risk, sell to retailers, and pay us a royalty every quarter. We approve their products and supply style guides every year, so there's work, but they do the heavy lifting. It's the Disney model. Disney licenses Mickey and Minnie and Toy Story to people like us, and we pay them a royalty. When you can extend into movies and TV, that's a franchise.

How do you go after licenses like Monster Jam?

We have a whole department that looks for licenses and builds presentations. For a master toy license, you present maybe 40 ideas, and it takes months. Our biggest partnership is Monster Jam. We had a 10-year partnership and just renewed for another 10. We have an incredible relationship with Universal and do Gabby's Dollhouse. Sometimes something comes out of nowhere, like Cocomelon, or Ms. Rachel, which we caught early as a YouTube and Instagram sensation. And sometimes the big studios come to us: "We're doing Toy Story 5. Do you want to bid?"

When were you able to breathe again after Bakugan?

When you're growing again. As long as you're growing, you feel in rhythm, in flow. You still have a lot of humility and stay conscious that things could change. But if you see the trajectory growing, you know you're on stable ground. We went from $450 million to over $2 billion, partly PAW Patrol, but there's a lot of other stuff in there, including a lot of acquisitions.

What did you learn from Bakugan that you applied to PAW Patrol?

Put out a new TV show every single year. After Bakugan's fourth year, when it started going down, we stopped producing the show. One of the biggest mistakes we ever made. We also declined a $100 million movie from Universal. Biggest mistake we ever made. There's a rule in the toy industry that you can bring a toy back to a new generation if you retire it for seven years, and a film would've delayed that by two years. But it's so hard to get a film made, and someone wanted to invest $100 million to create a body of work for your fans, plus probably $20, $30, $40 million in advertising we weren't going to pay for. The film could've been incredible and relaunched the franchise. When you're in your 20s, there's the power of not knowing. You go with your gut. When you intellectualize things, you overthink them and think you're smarter than you are. Ben and I made that decision when we were 40, and I'd worked on that movie for three years. Now we produce films in-house here in Canada. When we went to all the studios to make a PAW Patrol film, everybody turned us down, so we said we'll fund it ourselves. We were 50% through development when Paramount came in.

What's the worst thing about running a public company?

It's like wearing different underwear. I don't think there's anything bad, to be honest. I'm so happy Spin Master is public, and I would not go back. First, there's full transparency. The balance sheet, income statement, cash flow are open to the outside world, and that means a lot to licensors like Monster Jam and Disney. They want to know you're stable and you'll be around, especially as a master toy licensee. We probably have $400 or $500 million of revenue from licenses, and I'd attribute a lot of that to transparency. Second, everybody inside knows the score. In a private company, no one knows the bottom line. Third, everybody's an owner, and it's the most flexible way to share ownership. Fourth, quarterly reporting makes you a healthier company. You have to manage the business so you don't have declines like we had as a private company. There are more eyes on you, accountability goes up, and accountability creates higher standards. The part that probably eats people the most is the dislocation between the share price and what's sitting in your enterprise, or getting knocked for capital allocation when the returns will take three, four, five years. We've been in business 32 years. We want to be in business 100 years. You have to have fortitude, and know the share price is a moment in time. It hasn't changed the assets sitting inside the business. I look maybe once a quarter.

How did you decide to step down as CEO?

It's difficult. It's a feel thing. When your life goals change and you want to spend your time differently, and when you want the business to live beyond the founders, you need to start transitioning to other people. When you hit 50, you're on the back nine. The truth for me is I needed a rest. I needed to get off the treadmill. We started at 23, and I stepped down at 50, so 27 years. If I wanted to keep contributing, I needed a rest. So I took a sabbatical for a year and a half and traveled. I spent five months in Africa. Two months in South Africa, then I drove by myself from Cape Town to Nairobi, about 5,000 miles over three months, through Namibia, Botswana, Zambia, Malawi, Tanzania, and Kenya. Everybody thought I was crazy. The nicest people, and the feeling that you're with Mother Earth. People are poor but happy, and very present. I'll never forget hiking with a guide and giving him some almonds. I'm four or five almonds in, and he's eating the first one nice, slow, relaxed. They vibrate at a different frequency than us.

How do you balance being on the board without undercutting management?

It's a very difficult balance, and I'm better at it today than I was at the beginning. We were operators, so you want to get involved. You stick to the macro things: making sure the culture is preserved, which is one of the most important things; capital allocation, which is a board member's responsibility; and M&A, which still sits with us as a board and founders. Then you trust the judgment of management and the CEO. They're going to bake the cake slightly differently than you would. You make sure you chose right, make sure they feel supported, give them your wisdom, and know they'll do things differently but get the same results.

How do you feel about the tariff fight between the U.S. and Canada?

I think it's transitory. When you've been in business 32 years, you've seen a lot, and you can't get too attached to this specific moment. It'll pass, and we have to manage through it. It's out of our control. I feel bad for the consumer, because tariffs are really a hidden tax. A more honest tax would be a sales tax. Last year it was a huge disruption for everybody in consumer products. Retailers stopped ordering for about two months in April and May and ordered less the rest of the year. Consumers spent less, prices went up, and it came off the back of COVID inflation. Then the irony is the government had to pay the tariffs back. Economies thrive on predictability. Some toy companies went out of business last year because of tariffs, so we lost jobs and innovation. For us, the most important thing is having great products that resonate with the consumer. That'll power through any situation: COVID, tariffs, anything. And Canadians love Americans, and Americans love Canadians. I love how Americans make fun of our moose and beavers and maple syrup. We're so blessed to live in North America. We don't know how good we have it. We should focus on lifting each other up, because there are so many other problems in the world. This is like a family fight. We're like amazing cousins, and we're headbutting, and it's just a lot of wasted energy.

How do you keep the childlike spirit of toys while running a public company that has to grow?

We will not put things out just for the sales. It just won't happen. We want to bring super innovative products to kids, and we have a huge responsibility for what we bring to market. A lot of times our taste is wrong and it doesn't resonate, but it was never, "We need another $50 million of revenue, so let's sell this." That doesn't exist in this company.

Are physical toys still a thing with screens and AI?

More so than ever. I would've thought it would shift more to gaming and digital, and it's actually growing. Parents want their kids to physically engage with physical products, and adults want real-life experiences too. They want to get off the screen. There's a whole movement toward analog. That's why the '90s are so hot. As human beings we love to touch and use our hands and our imagination, and I don't think that's going to change. Screens aren't going away either, so it's up to parents to decide what's healthy for their kids. It's an "and," both together.

What would you do if you were starting a toy company today?

Probably what we just paid a lot of money for. We just bought a product called Sticker Box. You press a button and speak into it, "Make me a sticker of a pony riding an airplane in the desert," and four seconds later the image prints out with a thermal printer inside. It's the first-ever generative AI physical product brought to market. Kids don't even know it's AI, because kids don't care about tech. So if I were starting today, I'd marry AI and physical products to bring innovation to the table. I told the people we bought it from, "You'll go down in history. You created the first physical generative AI product for kids." I wish we'd come up with it internally, but we're bigger and slower.

What are the biggest brands you've acquired?

Melissa & Doug is probably the most famous. Tech Deck. Gund, the oldest stuffed animal brand in North America, back to the 1890s. The Rubik's Cube. Toca Boca. Etch A Sketch.

Is "start in your 20s, take the risk" easier to say now that you've succeeded?

I can say it because I lived it and can look back. If you'd asked me in the moment, I'd have said I'm not thinking about it, I'm just doing it. But there are things that accrue to you in your 20s no matter when you're born. The greatest thing you have going for you is that you're close to the zeitgeist. You practically are the zeitgeist. In business, the most important thing is seeing the white space and filling it, and you see the world with fresh eyes. I write a chapter called "Everybody's Rooting for You." When you're 25 and you walk into a retailer or supplier and want better terms, no one sees you as competition. It's harder at 35, when you're supposed to know what you're doing, and harder still at 50. We want young people to succeed, because we remember what it's like, and because older people love being around their energy and that bright-eyed sense that anything's possible. With Earth Buddies, our payables were 90 days and our receivables were net 20. We had a 70-day float, so we didn't have to raise money and kept more equity. There's no way we'd get that at 35 or 40. Everybody took our calls. Sometimes knowing too much works to your disadvantage. And finding partners is easier when you're young and socializing. When you hit 35, 40, life gets more insular. The misnomer is that you need a body of experience before you go into business because it's less risky. I write a chapter called "The Inverse Risk": it's riskier not to bet on yourself. If you're passionate, you'll de-lever the risk and work that much harder. And your ability to work hard in your 20s is 5X what it is at 35 with two kids, a mortgage, and a flight to catch. Those things will be there for every generation. I'm an eternal optimist. With all the disruption coming in business, disruption favors the young and innovative, not the bigger companies.

How do you feel about the perception of wealthy businesspeople?

I find it very distasteful when people lead with the word billionaire. What does that have to do with anything? Talk about the products we put into the world, how we've impacted kids' lives and brought joy. Talk about the thousands of jobs we've created and the careers. We have a saying at Spin Master that the best place to start your career is in shipping. We have people who started in shipping who are SVP of sales, SVP of M&A. People who've been here 20, 25 years. Toy legends in this building. A woman who ran our entertainment division now greenlights movies at Paramount. One of the greatest things about having your own business is you create your own culture, your own world: how you treat people, how you pay people, what equity you give. I'll never forget when we opened our L.A. office and someone walked in wearing flip-flops. Shorts is one thing, flip-flops is a bit much. But business is more of an art than it is about profit and loss. It's about the environment you create and how you treat people. I understand how people feel about certain businesspeople, but don't paint everybody with a wide brush. Come walk into Spin Master and feel the energy, then decide. A better question is what I'm doing with my money. I have a foundation. We support homeless people and kids with learning disabilities, among other projects. At Spin Master we have a program called the Toy Movement, which I started in 2014. We bring millions of toys to kids in displaced regions around the world. I've personally delivered toys to kids displaced from Syria in Jordan, gone to Ukraine in 2022, and to Erbil in Iraq. Businesses are so multifaceted.

Younger generations now see big business leaders as predatory. What do you make of that?

It's very nuanced, and it's hard to judge from the outside. You need to know the individuals, so I won't comment on specific people. Here in Canada we're soft capitalists. We have healthcare for everybody and incredible social programs, and it works. I'm a big believer in free enterprise, in people being entrepreneurial and bringing new things into the world. The irony is that if you want more redistribution of wealth, we need more entrepreneurs, more small businesses, 10X or 100X more. It's innovation that pulls the consumer from here to there when they're all aggregating in one place. Maybe some companies get so large they have too much of a monopoly. I'm not a believer in monopolies. A monopoly is an unfair advantage, not an even playing field. Those are the constructs I'd look at. But free markets are the healthiest thing. And consumers can vote with their actions. If you don't like a company, stop using their products, and get other people to do the same. Companies will change their behavior faster than anything else, and they'll start to lose their monopoly. Scott Galloway talks about this a lot. I'm all about accountability and the things we can control.

So what's your advice?

We need to support young people to take more risks and have more agency, and to have equity. Do you know how you get equity? You just start. You give it to yourself. The moment you start your own business, you have 100% equity in something. You don't have to wait for someone to give it to you. You decide you want to go into business for yourself, find what that is, and work toward it. It may not work the first time or the second. You'll have learning luck, and eventually you'll hit on it. The Beatles weren't great at the beginning. They played shitty bars for years. People grind it out getting better at their craft. If you want to create wealth, start your own business, give yourself 100% equity, then divide it among 10 or 15 people with totally different skills, and bring something into the world you see differently. And don't harp on other people. I'm not a big believer in relying on the government to save you. No one's coming to save you. Look through history. The only person who's going to save you is yourself.

Previous
Previous

“Every CEO Is Replaceable”

Next
Next

The Netflix Documentary, the Cheating Scandal and 10M Daily Users